Summarised Proofs Showing
Fundamental Errors of
“Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith UK”
now known as
“Green Lane Mosque”
Many of these errors are in relation to the Salafi Manhaj as you will see. The noble Scholar Shaykh Badi'ud-Deen Shaah As-Sindee (rahimahullaah) was amongst the first scholars to speak against the errors of this organisation in the UK. After him the Muhaddith and 'Aalim Muqbil bin Haadee spoke against one of its leaders, Suhaib Hasan, and the group itself. So please read the detailed thread (provided on Salafitalk.net) from the viewpoint of the evidences after you have read the summarised points below - and knowing that the 'ulemah have spoken regarding this group.
Shaykh Ibn Baaz (rahimahullaah) stated in a fatwa: "So the speech of so-and-so is accepted not because it came from so-and-so, but rather because it is in accordance to the truth. And the speech of such-and-such is not rejected [merely] because it came from such-and-such, but rather because it opposes the truth."
DEVIATION PART 1
Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith UK Support Democratic Elections And Attribute It To Islaam
The "Head" Of Markaz Jamiat Ahle-Hadith, Abdul-Hadi Umari, Gives Fatwa That Democratic Elections Are Supported By The Sharee'ah & One Is Sinful If He Does Not Vote, Thereby Someone Corrupt Is Elected!!
DEVIATIONS PART 2
Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith UK DEMAND Democracy Be Restored In Algeria.
They Demand FIS, Islamic Salvation Front (Takfeeree Algerian Group) To Be Given Authority
DEVIATIONS PART 3
Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith UK Invite Heads Of Innovated Groups To Deliver Lectures At Their 16th Annual Conference.
From Those Invited:
1. Head Of Islamic Foundation - Followers Of Abul-Aala Mawdoodee.
2. SM Darsh - Soofee, Ash'aree - Islamic Sharee'ah Council.
And others...
DEVIATIONS PART 4
"Head/Ameer" Of Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith UK Praises & Exalts The Knowledge Of:
(i). Founder Of The Brelewee Soofee Cult.
(ii). Syed Abul-Aala Mawdoodee
(iii). Scholar Of The Deobandee Hanafee Deviant Sect.
Abdul-Hadee Al-Umaree (Ameer of the 'Jamiat') delivered on a Radio Station in Birmingham, UK, in the month of Ramadaan which reaches out to tens and thousands of Muslim that Ahmad Ridhaa Brelewee (the one who called openly to major Shirk and major Kufr), Shabeer Ahmad Uthmaanee Ad-Deobandee, Syed Abul-Aala Mawdoodee are great scholars who have provided a great service to Islaam - he praises them over and over again, to the point of exaggeration! Not even mentioning a single point of criticism of them or their sects! He does not once mention Shaykh Ibn Baaz, Shaykh Al-Albaanee, Ibn Al-Uthaymeen or the scholars of this time.
DEVIATIONS PART 5
Suhayb Hasan Of Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith UK Attacks The Scholars Of Salafiyyah And Shaykh Rabee' In Specific.
Suhayb Hasan vehemently attacks Shaykh Rabee' Bin Haadee. He states that people should listen to the refutations of the deviant Ash-Shaayijee against the noble Shaykh Rabee' Bin Haadee. He also contends the detailed refutations of Shaykh Rabee' upon Abdur-Rahmaan Abdul-Khaaliq of Jam'iyyah Ihyaa Turaath Al-Islaamee. He also claims to be a contemporary of Shaykh Rabee'!!
Suhayb Hasan has been refuted by Al-Allaamah Muqbil Bin Haadee al-Waadi'ee on tape. That tape is available from SalafiBookstore.com
DEVIATIONS PART 6
Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith UK Clearly State That They Are With The Kuwaiti Jam'iyyah Ihyaa Turaath Al-Islaamee
In an interview with al-Furqaan Magazine (in Arabic), a head of the 'jamiat ahl-e-hadith' states that it is obligatory to co-operate with the Jam'iyyah Ihyaa Turaath Al-Islaamee.
This Ihyaa Turaath has been refuted in detail by many scholars including Shaykh Muqbil bin Haadee, Shaykh 'Ubayd Al-Jaabiree, Shaykh Ahmad Subaa'ee etc. These tapes are available from Salafi Publications.
DEVIATIONS PART 7
Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith (now known as Green Lane Masjid) UK Visit House Of Lords (Parliament); Mixing With Shee'ah In The Name Of Politics; Taking Part In Open Photo Opportunities With Kufaar & Shee'ah
In photos from a local Newspaper it is apparent that the heads of the 'Jamiat' are posing for photos along with some very unsavory characters. From those present were representatives from the Raafidah Shi'ah seen alongside Abdul-Haadee sipping drinks. You can see in the attached newspaper clipping, Abdul-Haadee Umaree ("Ameer"), Sher Khaan Jameel (Imaam of Green Lane Mosque) and "Lord" Nadheer Ahmad (a regular speaker/lecturer at Ahl-e-Hadeeth Conferences) and others.
DEVIATIONS PART 8
"Lord" Ahmad Nadheer, A Regular Speaker At The Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadeeth Conferences & Seminars, Builds Bridges With Shee'ah & Visits Iran!
The magazine cuttings are shocking. If these incidents narrated were merely narrated to us, we would find them extremely difficult to believe. But see for yourselves on the detailed thread on SalafiTalk.net!
DEVIATIONS PART 9
Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith Publish Booklet Promoting Innovators & Callers To Deviation
A booklet was published in Urdu, English and Arabic and distributed freely in tens of thousands. This book mentions that from the "expert scholars and devoted reformers" are:
"Imaam" Muhammad Abduh
Muhammad Rasheed Ridaa
Hasan Al-Banna
Muhammad Al-Ghazaalee
Muhammad Mutawalli Sha'rawee
Laa hawla wala quwwata illa billaah!
DEVIATIONS PART 10
Suhaib Hasan Indicates That Dispute Between Shaykh Rabee' Bin Haadee and Abdur-Rahmaan Abdul-Khaaliq Of Ihyaa Turaath Is Based Upon Them Being Contemporaries.
DEVIATIONS PART 10a
Suhaib Hasan Claims That The Science Jarh wa Ta'deel (Disparaging & Praising) Is Not Applicable In Our Times.
DEVIATION PART 11
Suhayb Hasan Invites The Deviated Hizbee Adnaan Ar'oor To His Masjid In London For An Intensive Islamic Course!!
DEVIATION PART 12
Suhayb Hasan Delivers Lecture Alongside
The Well-Known Surooree/Qutubee Abu Muntasir.
Their Chosen Lecture Is: "UNITY" !!
DEVIATION PART 13
Suhayb Hasan Invited to Deliver Lectures For Ikhwaanee Organisation Alongside Heads Of Deviation:
Raashid Ghanoushi
Dr. Jamaal Badawee
and many more...
DEVIATION PART 14
Suhayb Hasan's Sharee'ah And Fatwa Council.
With him on the "Sharee'ah Council" we find Soofees, Ash'arees and Ikhwaanees.
DEVIATION PART 15
Suhayb Hasan's "Sharee'ah Council" has upon it "Scholars" who represent the following Mosques and Sects:
1. Jamia Mosque & Islamic Centre, Birmingham
Soofees/Ikhwaanees
2. Islamic Centre, Didsbury, Manchester
Hamas/Ikhwaanees
3. Islamic Center, Glasgow
4. Markazi Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith, UK !!!
5. Jamia Masjid Hanafiya, Bradford.
Brelewees Soofees
6. UK Islamic Mission
The Jamaa'ah Of Mawdoodee
7. Da'watul-Islam, UK.
8. Muslim World League.
9. London Central Mosque & Islamic Cultural Centre.
10. Muslim Welfare House Ikhwaanees
Then the statement of this so-called "Sharee'ah Council" goes on to say:
"The SCHOLARS representing these centres come from all MAJOR SCHOOLS OF THOUGHT among the Sunnis"
So according to Suhayb Hasan and this "Markazi Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith, UK", the Brelewee Soofees, Ikhwaanul-Muslimoon and the followers of Mawdoodee all are from Ahlus-Sunnah!!
Are these the people you want solving your marital and religious problems? Wallaahul-musta'aan!
DEVIATION PART 16
Suhayb Hasan
Upon "European Council For Fatwa And Research"
alongside:
Yusuf Al-Qardawi (President)
Rashid al-Ghanouchi and many more from the various groups of Sufism, al-Ikhwaan al-Muslimoon, Deobandiyyah, etc...
On page 1 of "Fatwas Of European Council For Fatwa And Research", Islamic INC Publishing and Distribution, Egypt, it states:
"The inaugural meeting of the European Council for Fatwa and Research was held in London, UK on 21-22 Dhul Qi'da 1417AH (29-30 March 1997). The meeting was attended by more than 15 scholars who responded to the invitation of the 'Federation of Islamic Organisations in Europe'. This meeting saw the endorsement of the Draft Constitution of the ECFR."
On page 7, same book, it states that they have had 8 meetings till the date of publication:
"The Eighth Session, in Valencia, Spain between 26 Rabi' Thani to 1 Jumada Al-Awwal 1422 AH, 18-22 July 2001."
DEVIATION PART 17
Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith And Democratic Elections
Ahl-e-Hadith Green Lane Host the 'Respect' Socialist Party Candidate Followed by Q and A with her.
She then headed for Small Heath's Ahl-e-Hadith Green Lane Mosque to address a Nigerian Forum meeting attended by over 200 and stressed the importance of voting and why 'Respect' deserved their votes and why they deserved 'Respect'. This was followed by a Q&A session after which Salma dashed off to do a spot of committed canvassing during which she received numerous calls from shop owners requested posters for their shop windows…
See also 'Deviation Part 1' where Abdul-Hadi Al-'Umri (one of the head's of the 'Jamiat' and their mufti) obligates voting upon the people and regards as sinful the one who does not vote, and therefore liable for punishment from Allaah! He further claims that the Sharee'ah supports democratic elections!
DEVIATION PART 18
Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith Endorses The Respect Party Of George Galloway & Encourages Muslims to Vote for it's Female Candidate
A number of high profile Muslim Imams and religious leaders have endorsed the candidacy of Birmingham Sparkbrook and Small Heath candidate Salma Yaqoob. Below is a statement of support from the faith representatives. Yesterday, a further 10 imams and leaders added their names to the endorsement list at a meeting at the Birmingham Central Mosque...
Signed By: "Mufti" Abdul Majid Nadeem,
Mohammed Sarfraz Madni,
"Maulana" Abdul Hadi,
"Maulana" Sher Khan Jamil Al-Amri,
"Maulana" Dr Abdul Rab Saqib,
Allama Mohammed Khalid,
Maulana Abdul Salaam Rashdi,
Qari Mohammed Tayyab,
Hafiz Mohammed Arif,
Maulana Karamallah Al-Khairi,
"Maulana" Abdul Karim Saqib,
"Maulana" Dr. Akhtar Al-Zaman Ghauri.
Who Is George Galloway?
Heads of the Jamiat Declare Open Support for this Socialist Party.
The photo in the detailed thread on salafitalk.net is that of George Galloway acting like a cat - purring and drinking milk out of a woman's hand.
In another scene Galloway wears a woman's swimming costume...
DEVIATION PART 19
"JAMIAT AHL-E-HADITH"
& THEIR AGREEMENT WITH THE DEVIANT
HASAN AL-BANNAH & THE AFFAIR OF
UNITY WITHOUT LIMITS!
HAFEEZ ULLAH KHAN OF JAMIAT AHL-E-HADITH UK SUPPORTS THE FALSE PRINCIPLE OF HASAN AL-BANNA ON TV
Hafeez Ullah Khan, one of the heads of the ‘Jamiat’:
“The whole purpose of this discussion is that the Ummah is a victim of splitting and splintering – it is in dire need of unity and strength and brotherhood. My friends, me stating this does NOT mean that the Religious and Islamic organizations that exist have to lose their specific identities and titles and become one entity – No, but rather every organization and every jamaa’ah should remain established upon their own individual identities and come together making their unity apparent and it is in this unity that the blessing lies…”
(‘Itihad – Unity Muslim’ Channel, 7th September 2006)
DEVIATION PART 20
JAMIAT AHL-E-HADITH UK AFFIRM THEIR SCHOLARS. FROM THEM THE HEAD OF IKHWAANUL-MUSLIMOON :- HASAN AL-BANNAH!!
The following shows the 'scholars' this Jamiat claims attachment to. Look and see how they mix truth with falsehood:
"And in this time also, the Islamic Da'wah have been established in Shaam (Syria, Palestine, Lebanon, Jordan) and in Egypt and in North Africa and in the Arabian Peninsula by unique/exemplary Scholars, leaders of Rectification, from the likes of Jamaalud-Deen Al-Qaasimee, Imaam Muhammad Abduh, Shaykh Muhammad Rasheed Ridhaa, and SHAYKH HASAN AL-BANNAH, Shaykh Muhammad al-Ghazaalee, Shaykh Muhammad Mutawali Ash-Sha'raawee, Imaam Muhammad ibn Abdul-Wahhaab and the Imaams from his offspring and his students, and from them the noble Imaam Shaykhul-Islaam 'Abdul-'Azeez ibn Abdullaah ibn Baaz - may Allaah raise them in repute and level."
(From the freely distributed book, "Ad-Da'wah ilallaah, Manhajuhaa wa Muqadimmatuhaa" ("The Call To Allaah, It's Methodology and it's Advancement") Published by 'Markazi Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith (UK)' Green Lane, Birmingham, 1999)
DEVIATION PART 21
THEY SAY WE MUST VOTE FOR SALMA YAQOOB!?
And what is even worse is the political activists of the "Jamiat Ahl-e-hadeeth" endorse voting for a muslim woman (Salma Yaqoob), of a social party who made allowable suicide killings in Iraaq and Palestine openly in a BBC interview.
Salma Yaqoob of the Socialist Respect Party:
QUESTION:Should Muslims make any distinction between how acceptable suicide bombings are in foreign countries - such as Palestine and Iraq - and how acceptable they are in the UK?
SALMA YAQOOB ANSWERS: "Yes, I think they should [make a distinction]. The people of Iraq and Palestine are fighting wars to end brutal occupations. Suicide killings there are a symptom of the unevenness of forces and desperation of the people defending themselves against attacks by some of the most powerful military machines in the world. Even according to the UN people have the right to physically resist and defend themselves..."
(Source: "Violence in religion's name.", Panorama, BBC.co.uk)
She then goes on to claim that that suicide killings are, however, unjustified in the UK! So justified in Iraq and Palestine but not in London!!
So this is the person who the 'Jamiat' promotes, endorses and supports and makes obligatory upon the people to vote for? This is the person whom the 'Jamiat' invite to their Masjid and claim that not to vote for her can result in sin and corruption?!
DEVIATION PART 22
SALMA YAQOOB THE ELECTION CANDIDATE ENDORSED OFFICIALLY BY THE "JAMIAT AHL-E-HADITH", STATES:
THAT IF SHE WAS IN SAUDI ARABIA, SHE WOULD CAMPAIGN AGAINST THE HIJAAB!
What was shocking is that Salma Yaqoob says:
"In Iran and Saudi Arabia the Hijaab is a tool of oppression because it is forced on women and if I was there I would campaign against it"!!
Note, O reader, this woman representative of the Socialist party has been endorsed officially by the the Jamiat, she has visited GREEN LANE MOSQUE, the UK centre of the "Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith" and lectured there!
Heads of the 'Jamiat', such as Abdul-Haadee Omari, have stood upon podiums and delivered verdicts obligating Muslims to vote for her.
DEVIATION PART 23
Suhaib Hasan Joins Celebration of Prophet’s Birthday!!
From a cut-out from the “The Muslim News” dated 20th May 2003, page 7.
It shows Suhaib Hasan of the “Jamiat Ahle-Hadith UK”, with the Conservative Party and other Muslim organisations celebrating the so-called Birthday of the Prophet, may the peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him.
A picture speaks a 1,000 words (Suhaib Hasan is far right) in the detailed thread from SalafiTalk.net!
DEVIATION PART 24
ABU USAMAH KHALIFAH ADH-DHAHABI & HIS SPEECH CONCERNING THE ISLAMIC GOVERNMENTS:
HE IS AN OFFICIAL EMPLOYEE, A KEY LECTURER, A KHATEEB,
& AN IMAAM OF THE "MARKAZI JAMIAT AHL-E-HADITH UK"
AT GREEN LANE MOSQUE
Abu Usaamah Khaleefah adh-Dhahabee, stated in the year 2000, during a sermon delivered in the USA:
"You are all aware of the astronomical and extortionate amounts we are paying for one gallon of gas - about a dollar 50, 65, 70 cents for a gallon of gas... and that's from their politics and games!
What's the point? The point is that Allaah has given the Imaams of the Muslims the great big Imaam, this black gold! - that if they wanted they could use this gold as a weapon against these infidels and bring them literally to their knees calling - but what do we find the imaams of the muslims doing? Bickering and fighting amongst themselves, going to the devils and asking the devils to solve their problems [saying],
'What do you want to do Mr Devil with the situation?' - so we have the states that are in the 'khaleej' or the gulf, Saudi Arabia being the main one, trying to help the Devil to keep the prices up so that their infrastructure here [in the USA] can get blessed, and then we have the other smaller poorer countries saying, 'NO! let's do something else' - and the people are arguing and fighting amongst themselves - Why?
Because ALL of them put the Book of Allaah (tabaraka wa ta'aala) behind their back and they put the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allaah (salallaahu alayhi wasallam) on the side!
And with all of that there is no point of meeting for those people.. the devils are gonna be coming for them...."
DEVIATION PART 25
'LORD NAZIR', A KEY SPEAKER FOR MARKAZI JAMIAT AHLE-HADITH UK STATES "NIQAAB IS PURELY CULTURAL"!!
'Lord' Nazir Ahmed has always been seen by the Markazi Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith as one of their own, who has 'made it' into the political arena. They always state and claim that he is a good ahle-hadith person who aids Islaam and the Muslims and is a protector of the rights of Muslims in the UK.
Green Lane Mosque, the headquarters of Jamiat Ahle-Hadith UK, have invited year after year, conference after conference, even after event, as a speaker and lecturer.
So now Nazir Ahmed has taken yet another step in misrepresenting Islaam:
"The veil is now a mark of separation, segregation and defiance against mainstream British culture.
"But there's nothing in the Koran to say that the wearing of a niqab is desirable, let alone compulsory. It's purely cultural. It's an identity thing which has been misinterpreted.."
http://www.middle-east-online.com/english/?id=19692
http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/this_britain/article2290058.ece
A Series of Proofs and Articles Showing Fundamental Errors of
"Markaz Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith UK" with its roots in Pakistan & India
